Skip to the tool
Sump Pump Cost Calculator

Provenance

Sources and update log

Methodology is a snapshot: every constant this site holds today, with its label, its source, and its quote. This page is the film instead of the photograph — a dated record of what changed in that snapshot, when, and why, so a reader who checked this site six months ago can see what moved without re-reading every constant to find out.

Change log, most recent first

2026-09-24 — content pass: worked examples, price drivers, quote reading, when not to install, regional factors

Added six pages: two households run end to end through the calculators (worked examples), what moves an installed quote (price drivers), how to check a quote against the scope tool (how to read a quote), when a pump is the wrong fix (when not to install), what genuinely varies by place (regional factors), and this page.

No new priced figure was added to this site's records in this pass. This site's standing rule (see the refusal list on methodology) is that a figure is published only after a live or archived verification with a stored quote — never from memory or from a summary of what a source is believed to say. Two data series identified while writing this pass have not cleared that bar, so neither is published; both are logged below as open items rather than guessed at. The new pages were built entirely from the 14 figures already on file, run through this site's own calculators.

2026-08-24 — three provenance defects corrected in one pass

A review of every page that cites a source found three defects in how this site had been presenting its own evidence, all corrected the same day:

  • A fabricated USGS quote. The roof-example figure had been carrying a sentence this site wrote itself — "a roof of '40 x 70 feet' yields '1,743' gallons... from a 1-inch rainstorm" — inside quotation marks attributed to the agency. Every number in it was correct, but the sentence was ours, not USGS's, and quoting our own prose as a federal agency's words is a false attribution regardless of whether the numbers check out. It now carries the actual table row verbatim, with the reading of it moved outside the quotation.
  • A false "live" access claim. The USGS water-density figure (8.329 lb per gallon at 70F) was marked as quoting text present on the live page, but the sentence had since been removed from it. The access state was corrected to "archived", with three independent capture dates recorded as evidence the quote was genuinely published at that URL. The value did not change; the honesty of the access claim did.
  • A reconstructed EIA quote. The electricity-rate figure's quote had the table's title with a cell reading ("— residential, May 2026: 18.44") appended to it — a reconstruction, not an excerpt, rendered inside a blockquote as if EIA had written that whole sentence. It now carries only the table's own title, as read on the 2026-08-24 retrieval, with the cell reading moved to an unquoted note. That title carries a rolling end-date and will not match a live check made after that date without a fresh retrieval. The rate itself — 18.44 cents per kilowatt-hour — did not change in this correction; only the quote's honesty did.

The same day, the National Weather Service's own description of the Precipitation Frequency Data Server was quoted on the pit inflow test page, so a reader knows what they are being sent to before following the link.

2026-08-06 — sizing-first rebuild

The site was rebuilt around measured geometry rather than a national cost anchor. The USGS rainfall conversion (27,154 gal per acre-inch), the EPA's sanitary-sewer-overflow guidance on inappropriate connections, and the full set of derived unit conversions and labeled assumptions in the current registry were established on this date. The three defects corrected on 2026-08-24 above were introduced on this date and stood uncorrected for eighteen days before the review that caught them.

Open items — flagged, not guessed at

Two data series would make genuinely useful additions to this site, and neither has been added, because neither has cleared this site's verification bar yet — a live or archived primary-source quote, on file, before a figure is used:

Candidate figureWould improveWhy it is not in the registry yet
EIA state-level residential electricity price tableRegional cost factors — a true state-by-state operating-cost table in place of the rate-spread table currently thereThis is the same EIA publication as the already-sourced national rate, broken out by state. Adding it requires fetching the live table and recording per-state quotes and retrieval dates, which has not been done yet.
BLS Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics, plumbing and electrical tradesPrice drivers — a real regional labor-rate comparison in place of the current qualitative descriptionThe Bureau of Labor Statistics publishes wages by occupation and by metro area; this site names the series but has not quoted a specific figure from it, for the same reason.

Either addition, once genuinely sourced with a live quote and a retrieval date, would be published as a labeled, cited figure following the exact pattern every other constant on this site already uses — not as a number typed directly into a page.

How an entry gets added to this log

Every figure this site holds lives in one data module, and every one of them carries a retrieval date and a six-month review-by date, both visible on methodology. When a figure is added, corrected, or re-verified, the change is made in that module — never in page text — which is what keeps this log, the methodology table, and the pages that cite the figure from drifting apart. If you find a figure that looks stale or a source that has moved, the contact page is the fastest way to start a correction.

Why this page exists separately from methodology

A methodology page answers "what does this site currently claim, and on what evidence" — it is deliberately silent about history, because a snapshot has no tense. That silence is fine for a first-time reader and a real gap for a returning one, who has no way to tell a figure that has stood unchanged for a year from one that was corrected yesterday, short of comparing two copies of the page by hand.

This page is the other half of that transparency: not just what is claimed now, but what has changed, when, and why, plus the honest state of the things this site has considered adding and has not, with the reason stated rather than left for a reader to guess at. Reading both pages together — the current snapshot and its history — is closer to what a genuine audit trail looks like than either one alone.